What is the
Sarbanes-Oxley Act?
Cutting to the chase and through the hyperbole, it is a law enacted in
2002 that legislates record retention and prescribes standards for
corporate accountability. The essence of the Act are internal controls
and corporate governance. IT auditing is an element of compliance, as
well as the maintenance and administration of systems supporting all
facets of compliance.
IT? What's the
Connection?
Most of the resources discussing Sarbanes-Oxley lead in by citing recent
debacles, such as Enron, which may have been the catalyst, but certainly
were not precedents by any stretch of the imagination. For a precedent
in which IT did finally turn in corporate misdeeds you have to go back
to 1972 and review the Equity Funding scandal. The following excerpts
from an excellent series of articles by M. E. Kabay, published in
Network World Security Newsletter (01/21/02 and 01/23/02) spells out why
IT always has been an important part of the auditing process, and why
the requirements for ethics and whistleblower programs in the the
Sarbanes-Oxley Act touch everyone in IT:
"The computer problems occurred just before the close of the
financial year in 1964. An annual report was about to be printed, yet
the final figures simply could not be extracted from the mainframe. In
despair, the head of data processing told the president the bad news;
the report would have to be delayed. Nonsense, said the president
expansively (in the movie, anyway), simply make up the bottom line to
show about $10 million in profits and calculate the other figures so it
would come out that way. With trepidation, the data processing chief
obliged. He seemed to rationalize it with the thought that it was just a
temporary expedient, and could be put to rights later anyway in the real
financial books.
The expected profit didn't materialize, and some months later, it
occurred to the executives at Equity that they could keep the stock
price high by manufacturing false insurance policies which would make
the company look good to investors. They therefore began inserting false
information about nonexistent policyholders into the computerized
records used to calculate the financial health of Equity.
By late 1972, the head of data processing calculated that by the end
of the decade, at this rate, Equity Funding would have insured the
entire population of the world. Its assets would surpass the gross
national product of the planet. The president merely insisted that this
showed how well the company was doing.
The scheme fell apart when an angry operator who had to work overtime
told the authorities about shenanigans at Equity. Rumors spread
throughout Wall Street and the insurance industry. Within days, the
Securities and Exchange Commission had informed the California Insurance
Department that they'd received information about the ultimate form of
data diddling: tapes were being erased. The officers of the company were
arrested, tried and condemned to prison terms."
[The above is by M. E. Kabay in the 01/21/2002 issue of Network World
Security Newsletter]
From the above IT's responsibilities in conjunction with directly
supporting Sarbanes-Oxley compliance is clear - and it goes well beyond
mere IT auditing.
Where to Start?
'Manager's Guide to the Sarbanes-Oxley Act : Improving Internal Controls
to Prevent Fraud' is a good starting point for understanding what
Sarbanes-Oxley entails at a high level. Another basic book is
'What is Sarbanes-Oxley?'. You'll see the term internal audit
repeatedly when researching Sarbanes-Oxley, and a good starting point
for learning the basics of this function is
'The Internal Auditing Pocket Guide'. If you find yourself assigned
as a newly minted IT auditor
'Core Concepts of Information Technology Auditing' will get you
going in the right direction. Another book that covers IT auditing is
'Information Technology Control and Audit'. The latter goes into
more detail and is more suited for the working practitioner through to
intermediate level.
Once you have a basic understanding, I strongly recommend visiting
'Information Systems Audit and Control Association' and downloading
the free 84-page document titled "IT Control Objectives for
Sarbanes-Oxley." This document will focus on IT's role and
responsibilities.
For more general information, there is a commercial site that
provides news and updates on Sarbanes-Oxley issues
'sarbanes-oxley.com/', as well as the Public Company Accounting
Oversight Board
'pcaobus.org/', which provides rule making information and a means
to comment on proposed rules.
Where Next?
Section 404 of the Act contains much of what is going to concern IT. I
recommend reading
'How to Comply with Sarbanes-Oxley Section 404 : Assessing the
Effectiveness of Internal Control' to drill down into the gory
details. Another useful resource is
'Internal Audit's Role in Corporate Governance: Sarbanes-Oxley
Compliance', which tersely covers each of the Sections of the Act,
and comes with a CD ROM with editable templates that will save time.
This book is aimed more at the professional auditor, but will also give
IT professionals outside of the audit and internal controls domain
excellent insights.
'AuditNet' is a highly useful resource with a great deal of valuable
material in the Sarbanes-Oxley Audit Resource Center section of the
site.
Rounding out the general Sarbanes-Oxley resources is
'Sarbanes-Oxley and the New Internal Auditing Rules', which does
specifically cover IT issues, including ITIL and CObIT.
'Information Systems Audit and Control Association', previously
mentioned, is an excellent source of CObIT information.
This is a web-enabled world, so I strongly recommend reading
'Testing Web Security: Assessing the Security of Web Sites and
Applications', which takes an auditing approach to web security.
This book directly supports portions of Sarbanes-Oxley from an audit
perspective (although SOA is not mentioned in the book, the approach is
completely consistent with requirements.)
If you are an Oracle shop I strongly recommend getting a copy (or,
better, copies) of
'Oracle Privacy Security Auditing: Includes Federal Law Compliance with
HIPAA, Sarbanes Oxley & The Gramm Leach Bliley Act GLB'. This book
directly addresses how to use Oracle 9i facilities to achieve compliance
with parts of Sarbanes-Oxley.
End Notes
The following books will also indirectly support compliance efforts, and
are short reads that are thought-provoking:
-
'The Building Blocks Approach to Organization Charts',
'RoadMap: How to understand, diagnose, and fix your organization',
and
'Decentralization: Fantasies, Failings, and Fundamentals' will get
you thinking about how to most effectively build a healthy organization.
Healthy organizations foster ethics in the workplace.
-
'The Internal Economy: How to Apply Market Principles within
Organizations to Make Sense of Budgeting, Rate-Setting,
Project-Approval, and Accounting Processes', used in conjunction
with the above three books, will show how to build accountable
organizations at the department level.
-
'Outsourcing: How to Make Vendors Work for Your Shareholders' will
aid in critical decision making at the CxO level, which supports - to a
degree - corporate governance. |